Monday, October 20, 2014

China Blog Post

In the the passage written by Ban Zhao, titled "Lessons to Women", Zhao outlines the proper way for women to behave.  She emphasizes that women should be submissive and serve their husbands and their families.  Her passage relates easily to Fu Xuan’s poem “To Be a Woman” as in the poem he describes how a woman is thought to be less important than the men and the way they are expected to submit to men and how girls aren't as valued as men, even when they're first born they aren't celebrated the way boy babies are celebrated.  Zhao also mentions this in her piece when she mentions, "Now to lay the baby below the bed plainly indicated that she is lowly and weak, and should regard it as her primary duty to humble herself before others."  This idea contrasts greatly with the image that Fu Zuan gives us of boys when he says, "Boys stand leaning at the door/ Like Gods fallen out of Heaven."
The poem from Liu Xijun, “Lament,” is also a piece that shows the suppressed state of women at this time, and accents parts of Zhao's essay quite effectively.  Xijun talks about being married off into a strange land, and Zhao mentions that she was married and sent to serve in her husband's home when she was fourteen years old.  Xijun's last lines are, "O to be a yellow snow goose/floating home again!"  She longed to go home to be with her family, but Zhao seems not only content there with these strangers, but she seems to feel it is so much her duty that she wouldn't even want to be anywhere different.

All three of these sources show that women were oppressed and taught that they should be submissive and weren't worth as much as the men, but interestingly enough, Zhau's attitude toward the situation was opposite of the two poems.  She didn't seem to feel like there was anything wrong with it, it was just the way the world for her was and those were the duties she felt were important, while Xijun and Zuan felt bad for the women in their society.

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Antigone Review

Antigone is not your typical Greek hero, mostly because she is a woman, but she shares many heroic characteristics with those classic heroes such as Odysseus.  Like Odysseus, Antigone has nobility, she is courageous, and she has confidence in her own strength.  Odysseus shows his courage by going to war and bravely facing many dangerous situations, Antigone shows her courage by standing against Creon to do what she thinks is right.  Odysseus shows confidence in his strength by being a strong leader for his men and overcoming many trials in his long journey; if he didn't believe in his own strength, he wouldn't have been able to get through the situations they went through.  Antigone knows that if she breaks civil law to do what she feels is divine law and bury her brother that she will be killed, but because she knows her strength and knows what she wants to stand for, she show her confidence in herself and buries her despite knowing the consequences,  
In his funeral speech, Pericles mentions the Greek virtues, which are the power of adapting, versatility, and grace.  I don't think Antigone showed adaptability or versatility or else she probably would have been more obedient to Creon's law that her brother would not be buried.  She would have adapted to that change and went along with whatever Creon said.  While I don't think she displayed either of those characteristics, I think she did show grace as she accepted her punishment, even death, as a consequence of defying Creon to do what she felt was right.

Odysseus, on the other hand, I think showed all three virtues.  Over the course of his journey, he was put in many different situations and he had to adapt and be versatile to use different strengths of his, whether they be physical strengths or wit, to get himself and his men through the situations to get home, and through all these situations, he was still graceful and dignified.